Atrus & Catherine, Dudas sobre el final de Myst [ Outline ] · Standard · Linear+

[cosmodelia]

Hemos acabado el Myst, tras un tremendo atasco a la salida de la Era Selenita. Nos recordó al submarino de Riven, y también tuvimos que acabar mirando una guía para salir de esa pesadilla.

Bien, las dudas sobre el final de Myst son las siguientes:

La primera vez que vamos a ver a Atrus al final del juego nos dice que le ha encerrado allí Catherine, cosa que nos sorprendió, pues les creíamos enamorados.
Al volver con la hoja blanca nos dice Atrus que Catherine está prisionera, enlazando con el comienzo de Riven, en el que además Atrus está en la misma mesa de trabajo.
Y nos pide que la liberemos cuando en Myst dice que fue ella quien le encerró en D'ni!!!

Ya es todo esto contradictorio, pero más si al comienzo del juego recordamos que Atrus le ha dejado una nota y un vídeo...
[según recordamos encontramos más contradicciones pero estas bastan por ahora...]

¿Qué explicación teneis de esas contradiciones, o es fallo de doblaje?
¿Y cómo se entera Atrus encerrado en D'ni de qué su padre ha hecho prisionera a Catherine?

[CoolWind]

Siguiendo con la 'investigación' he encontrado la transcripción original de lo que dice Atrus la primera vez que le encontramos en Myst :

Who the devil are you? Don't come here to D'ni! Not yet! Oh, I have many questions for you, my friend, as you no doubt have for me. Where should I begin?


Perhaps my story is in order. My name is Atrus. I fear you've met my sons Sirrus and Achenar in the red and blue books on Myst island in my library. My library... it contains my works, my writings. I wrote many books. Many books that linked me to fantastic places. It's an Art I learned from my father many years ago.


But the red and blue books, those were different. I wrote those books to entrap overgreedy explorers that might stumble upon my island of Myst. But I had no idea my own sons would be entrapped.


My sons , Sirrus and Achenar. We had many journeys together. I gave them free reign to the books. Perhaps that was not wise. I could see the greed growing in them. I had not told them about the read and blue books. Their imaginations went wild. They dreamed of riches and power. Of course, they did not know the books were traps. They begged me for access to those books, and I, of course, denied them.


They devised a plan - an evil plan. I had no idea to what extent their greed had progressed. Their own mother... they used their own mother (oh, my dear Catherine) to lure me here to D'ni. Of course I could return to Myst, except that they removed a single page from my Myst linking book. I cannot return without that page.


You, my friend, can bring that page to me. Oh, I pray that you believe my story about the lies that my sons have told you. If you could find it in yourself to return that page to me here in D'ni, I could go to Myst and bring justice to my sons for what they've done.


I must return to my writing. I pray that you believe me. Please hurry. Bring the page. Bring the page with you.

Por tanto, da a entender que Catherine fue engañada por sus propios hijos 'traicionando' a Atrus.

Cuando tenga algo más lo escribo.